There’s a chapter of my life that remains stubbornly unfinished. Today, I will do more than finish it. I will respectfully, gracefully, dump this chapter into a six foot hole in the dirt. A funeral is closure for the living. Well, I’m living, and I could use some closure. So it’s funeral time, baby!
Inside the metaphorical casket next to me is my comedy career. I’m finally ready to say goodbye to my childhood dream.
When I was in elementary school, I wanted to be a cartoonist when I grew up. As I got older, my writing skills improved, but my drawing skills lagged far behind. So the dream crossfaded from cartoonist to comedian. In 7th and 8th grade, I recorded (terrible) audio sketch comedy tapes with my best friend Aidan. My comedy heroes fell into two buckets. One was vintage sketch comedy introduced to me by my dad and grandmother: Monty Python, Bob & Ray, The Muppets, and my guiding light, Stan Freberg, pictured above. Stan made many hit satirical comedy records and became a legendary voice actor. The second bucket was alternative sketch comedy from acts like The State, Kids in the Hall, and Mr. Show. One Halloween I went to school dressed as Adair from the Upright Citizens Brigade. No one had any idea who I was. My best non-human friend was Comedy Central.
When I think about my artistic output from middle school to high school, I was shockingly industrious in my pursuit of comedy! In middle school, I wrote and starred in a sitcom pilot for public access. In high school, I produced a comedy radio show with my friends, which aired on a local college station. (Callers said “these freshman suck,” but we were high school sophomores, so we were sucking at a college level!) I also directed, edited, and screened a comedy short film. But my greatest success was recording parody songs for MP3.com, where I earned $10,000 in royalties as a top artist on the platform. Not many kids from Buffalo are interviewed on New Zealand radio about their NSYNC song parodies… I assume? If you’re from Buffalo and you accidentally tricked Kiwis into going to McDonalds for NSYNC Happy Meal toys, please reach out.
Emerson College turbo charged my dream. I joined a proper sketch comedy group that was performing at a local theater. Just like The State, Kids in the Hall, and Upright Citizens Brigade! Would my sketch group, Atomic Powered Millionaires, reach the lofty heights of basic cable? As I waited for Comedy Central to call, I wrote and produced two comedy shows for the Emerson Channel, the college’s closed circuit TV station, along with a web series intended for Channel 101. (Work Warriors, my Street Fighter / The Office mash-up, didn’t make the cut, but it brought down the house at a packed screening on campus.) I hosted a children’s radio show, starred in a music video, and appeared in many silly short films. I was speed running my 10,000 comedy hours.
After college, I came out to Los Angeles. It took a few months of horrible PA work to land a gig as an Associate Editor at the National Lampoon’s website. I was intimately familiar with the National Lampoon Radio Hour through my father. The 70s sketch comedy show featured young Bill Murray, Harold Ramis, and Gilda Radner, among others. I had listened to my “Best Of” collection again and again. But 2005 was hardly 1975 at NatLamp. In the 90s, the website was a shadow of its former self as an edgy print comedy trailblazer. By the time I got there, the website was a shadow of the former website. This was not the fault of the very smart and funny editorial team, who took a chance hiring a nobody comedy nerd from Buffalo as an editor. The company was run by executives more interested in exploiting and embezzling from the comedy institution than bolstering it.
As luck would have it, comedy websites were a viable business in the mid-aughts, and they were looking for young (and cheap) writers. My National Lampoon credit meant something to the older generation of folks hiring for those website, who grew up on the lauded magazine. I parlayed that credit into dozens of freelance gigs at humor and pop culture sites like Buzzfeed, Cracked, Crave Online, Comedy.com, MadAtoms. There were many, many failed ventures that paid $50 a pop for funny listicles and parody articles. This was how I made a “living” as my comedy partner Asterios and I performed live at local theaters in LA. On YouTube, we teamed with our friend Joan to form Overtime Comedy. Our YouTube sketches racked up decent views for the time, but our output was inconsistent. We didn’t release content on a regular schedule and we didn’t lean enough into what worked. Overtime probably should’ve stuck with 1980s video game cartoon dubs, our biggest hits, but we insisted on making live action sketches to minimal fanfare. Though one person found me at a comic convention and said he showed our “Bank Codes” sketch to potential dates to see if they’d be compatible, which is pretty cool.
At the time, I felt stuck in the internet. All my major successes, from MP3.com to Mario in MySpace to my summer at the Warner Bros web series incubator, were internet based. My dream at this time was to be Steve Martin. I wanted to write and perform in TV and movies. I wrote spec pilots and features, sent them to agents, went to networking meetups, took improv classes, and performed at the UCB. I put in a lot of work. My problem was that I was bad at the friend-to-job pipeline. I didn’t hang out enough after shows. I didn’t work my existing connections hard enough. The few times my friends were in positions to hire comedy writers, they hired closer friends. I felt like a jerk. Or, more appropriately, The Jerk, limping away alone hauling a phone and a lamp and a table.
I was sick of writing comedy articles for failed websites. My TV and film career was a nonstarter. Inspired by the famous zine Army Man by Simpsons writer George Meyer, my wife Amanda and I launched a publishing house called The Devastator in 2010 with a tiny Kickstarter. We began as a print comedy magazine that ran for 13 issues, then switched to a full line press when we noticed readers were more interested in the “fake out” parody books we’d put on the reverse cover than the magazine itself. In retrospect, I’d say The Devastator was the high water mark of my professional comedy career. For eight years, we ran a small press, but we punched above our weight class in terms of distribution, critical praise, and contributor talent. Most importantly, we became a beacon for like-minded weirdos, many of whom are still close friends today. When I go to a comedy person’s house, it’s not uncommon to spot one or more Devastator books on their shelf. We were making funny and transgressive comedy for bookstore humor shelves stocked with dusty Garfield anthologies. Little did we know the headwinds we would run up against. Humor is a redheaded stepchild in the publishing industry, so we weren’t going to find investors or a bigger publisher to prop us up. We were also making short, cheap books on low margins thanks to overseas printing costs. Trump’s tariffs were a death blow to The Devastator’s already flimsy “business” model.
I didn’t have much of a comedy career after The Devastator stopped its presses. Amanda and I got hilariously close to producing an official Muppets sketch comedy podcast, which is one of the big “what ifs” in my career. We co-hosted a one season podcast for Sony Music called Dirt Cheap, which I still get compliments on every so often. I wrote kids comics for Disney, which I don’t think comedy people would count as “professional comedy,” even though the books were pretty funny. By the 2020s, the industry was changing. No one was reading specs anymore. I felt too old to go back to the comedy clubs and I had no desire to become a YouTube creator again. I like 20 minute videos about the history of Street Sharks, but I didn’t want to make them. It was around this time that my high school ambitions, which at one time felt like rocket fuel to a writer’s room, were drying up. For the first time in my life, I felt like I had no momentum. I hated that feeling.
My comedy career was over. I even told a friend or two out loud that I was quitting comedy. But I never really told myself. I think there’s been a tiny, barely flickering light still inside of me that has held out hope I would somehow, in some weird and unexpected way, achieve a traditional comedy career. When I was recently confronted with my old comedy writing, the psychic damage I took made me decide to finally extinguish that fire. And that’s what you’re reading. The official End of an Era… that actually ended a few years before the pandemic, if I’m being honest with myself.
My dream of being a professional comedy writer is succeeded by my successful career as a narrative designer and game creator. Even before I decided to pursue comedy, I was drawing level maps for imaginary video games on restaurant placemats. I drew comics inspired by Super Mario Land as a kid. Throughout my days as a comedy writer, I kept returning to the well of video games for inspiration. As I was focused on pursuing comedy, I ended up getting paid work writing MMORPGs, robot toys, and tabletop roleplaying games. I racked up writing credits on Assassin’s Creed, Street Fighter, and Dungeons and Dragons. My ability to write funny dialogue fast and well, a skill I learned in comedy, continues to be invaluable. A lot of my narrative design gigs have been for humorous games, but I get to do more than write jokes on those projects. I also get to be the kid drawing level maps in crayon. I’m still writing comedy professionally, but I’m not the comedy writer I imagined I’d become, and I never will be. I’m making peace with that now.
I’m no longer in hot pursuit of a big career dream. I just love what I do. I’m grateful for the opportunity to make games, whether it’s for myself or my clients. I’d be lying if I said writing this didn’t make me sad, but I’ve been delaying this funeral for far too long. The body was decaying. The stench was, uh, not great. So goodbye, comedy dream. I didn’t make it into a sitcom writer’s room. I never created an animated series for Comedy Central. But the dream guided me to a great career. The dream led me to Amanda, who I met at a comedy party in LA. The dream gave me so many incredible skills, cherished friends, and wonderful memories. I’m grateful for the dream.
Now to kick you into the grave, you son of a bitch. Love you!
🎲 Your Turn: This is an open mic eulogy! Are you ready to say goodbye to a childhood dream? An important hobby you no longer wish to maintain? A creative pursuit you’re ready to end? The floor is yours. Reply directly to this email or leave a comment on this page by hitting the orange button below. Since this is a funeral, feel free to leave a 🥀 in the comments.



2 responses to “Eulogy for My Childhood Dream”
🙏♥️🙏❤️🙏♥️
💖 💖 💖